Album Review: Moderat, "II" - Reverb

Album Review: Moderat, “II”

Moderat, "II"

Moderat, “II”

Moderat, “II”
(Monkeytown)

Moderat seems like it shouldn’t work. The group is the combination — in name and personnel — of German electro acts Apparat and Modeselektor. The former is better known for its experimental pop and the latter for its chilly, spasm-inducing production work.

Still, Moderat’s 2009 self-titled debut oozed charisma and appeal, taking sideways circuit-board skronk and adding infectious beats and damaged melodies. It evoked the feel of late-night European city that was both abandoned and dangerous, and it did it without resorting to hacky techno tricks.

“II” unfortunately falls into a few of those traps. It’s a different statement, to be sure, trading the insistence and bounce of the self-titled album for more contemplative and breathable spaces. And yet, the production also feels more claustrophobic, forcing listeners into a sonic bear-hug instead of holding them at comfortable arm’s length.

Single “Bad Kingdom” struts its R&B credentials with a verse that features Justin Timberlake-quality falsetto and a chorus dripping with George Michael’s rich, melodic soul. But many of the more mid-tempo tracks are light on ideas and texture, meditating on beats or sounds that aren’t all that interesting to start. It would be one thing if “II” was a straight-up ambient album, but splitting the difference between the occasional vocal-sampling track (“Gita”), gray-sky “interludes” like “The Mark” and “Clouded,” and go-nowhere traffic circles like “Versions” makes “II” feel less directed than its predecessor.

It’s got mood to spare, but like a forced piece of writing from an otherwise respected author, it overall comes off as stale and contrived, especially when we know the artist is capable of doing better.

Follow our news and updates on Twitter, our relationship status on Facebook and our search history on Google +. Or send us a telegram.

John Wenzel is an A&E reporter and critic for The Denver Post. Follow him @johntwenzel and @beardsandgum.

Share:
  • Patrick Martel

    What about Milk.

    • http://www.heyreverb.com/ John Wenzel

      “Milk” is definitely one of the more slow-building tracks, and while it doesn’t necessarily go anywhere it’s a nice example of Moderat uniting around an idea.