A long-time Nick Cave fan says "good riddance" to Grinderman - Reverb

Feature: A long-time Nick Cave fan says “good riddance” to Grinderman

Nick Cave, pre-Grinderman. Photo courtesy of the artist's Facebook.

Nick Cave, pre-Grinderman. Photo courtesy of the artist's Facebook.

This just in: Nick Cave’s mid-life crisis has ended.

Cave announced the break-up of his “rock” side project Grinderman at a recent festival performance in his native Australia.

Formed in 2006 with key current members of his long-time musical collective the Bad Seeds (Warren Ellis, Jim Sclavunos and Martyn P. Casey), Grinderman has, over the course of two records and various tours, been taking valuable time away from their more rewarding full-time gig.

I understand the idea of Grinderman and can respect it: Cave and his cohorts started the project as an outlet to get back to basic rock fundamentals and escape the “weight” of the Bad Seeds — lyrically, musically and even regarding the number of musicians within the band.

It’s also painfully clear that Cave was trying to recapture the dangerous energy of his early days with the Birthday Party (in my mind, the most perfect rock and roll band ever). And to his credit, it’s clear that even in his mid ’50s, it’s still slightly less embarrassing to see the Cave rocking out than it is other old school heroes. That’s only because he is still a man possessed by his art, who continually follows his muse even when it leads him to the wrong spot.

The Birthday Party — a young Cave along with Mick Harvey, Rowland S. Howard, Tracy Pew and Phil Calvert — was a violent, visceral, Euro art punk beast that ate up pieces of American blues, murder ballads and folklore and combined that with junkie sex and biblical history. In return they spat out thought-provoking lyrical bile and stinging shards of music as colorful, beautiful and cutting as stained glass.

With the Bad Seeds, Cave continued his lyrical trajectory, but placed it over a more mature, rich musical tapestry. Over the course of a number of successful albums completed with a rotating cast of musicians, Cave created a style of balladry and musical storytelling that not only weaved its way through his earlier influences, but reached a depth of dedication to craft that all artists should aspire to. Take a listen to the classic death row lament of “The Mercy Seat” or even the recent, humorous “Dig Lazarus Dig” for an example.

Alternately, Grinderman, offered fragments of songs, simplified rock runs and dirge-like, dirty grooves created under the guise of loose experimentation. Over that, Cave moaned off-the-cuff, lascivious lyrical musings with titles like “No Pussy Blues,” “Get It On” and “Worm Tamer.” It was interesting at first but really ended up just being sleazy (actually just creepy) and ultimately rang hollow and outlandish.

Maybe he just needed a break; it’s understandable given the amount and quality of work that Cave has given fans over the course of three decades now.

The youthful excitement of his work in the Birthday Party and the grace and wisdom of the Bad Seeds will continue to offer the challenges and rewards that the very best art always does. Conversely, Grinderman ends up kind of like the greasy, aging co-worker that continually tells you dirty jokes about their weekend trip to the strip club, forever unable to see that they’re really making you uncomfortable rather than entertaining you.

Follow our news and updates on Twitter, our whereabouts on Foursquare and our relationship status on Facebook. Or send us a telegram.

Michael Behrenhausen is a Denver-based writer, musician and regular Reverb contributor. The worst crime he ever did was play some rock ‘n’ roll.

  • The Truth

    LOL!  His early stuff was unlistenable.  Thank your god for YouTube, so you can see and hear the mess without spending any of your hard-earned $.  Why is it that critics are the only ones who like these experimental acts?  Same for movies, too.  I suppose they get so jaded that the only thing that can stir their pulse is by definition extremely unusual.  Three or four or more standard deviations away.  Sad, but understandable and almost inevitable–who wouldn’t become that way if they were supersaturated, too?  But for us 99.9%, it’s a well-written song that matters most.  No flow, no hook, no toe tapping, then no nothing.

  • Allen

    Mike, did you ever get to see GM on stage? I heard that was pretty awesome, and I’m sorry I won’t get the chance. I loved GM2, but I doubt that the small lineup could match the bad seeds show we saw a couple years back at the ogden. That was all-time.

    • Mbehrenhausen

      Hey Allen!

      I never did get to see Grinderman on stage – and I did hear they were great live – though yeah, I don’t think they could ever match the Bad Seeds at the Ogden. I liked some of the first Grinderman record (and still do), but absolutely could not stand the 2nd record. That’s what soured me on the whole idea. I found myself wishing Nick and the boys would have used that energy to infuse further Bad Seeds records – it certainly worked for “Dig Lazarus Dig!” which was fantastic.

  • Laura1973rowell

    RIP: Grinderman
    2nd best concert i ever saw was Grinderman (plus i got to meet the whole band…including St Nick)
    …the Best concert ever….Bad Seeds :-))

  • http://www.victoryandassociates.net Conan Neutron

    Idiocy, plain and simple. Grinderman is an age appropriate monster of rock that has nothing to do with the kind of ignoble and certain defeat of an “greasy, aging co-worker that continually tells you dirty jokes about their weekend trip to the strip club.”

    Nothing of the sort, it’s honest rock music with a streak of experimentalism that cuts out the phony rock ‘n roll trappings that we’ve grown accustomed to. It’s not all that rare to find, it’s just rare to be played by such passion and intensity by a bunch of aging dudes.

    It’s what the Stooges record “The Weirdness” SHOULD have been.
    It’s Raw Power without the foibles of trying to pretend that it’s half it’s age.
    You’ve clearly missed the point and the plot, and the fact that one of the categories for this is experimental/avant garde shows that completely.