Boston, Styx @ Red Rocks Amphitheatre | Reverb — Reverb Music — The Denver Post

Boston, Styx @ Red Rocks Amphitheatre

Boston and Styx (above) tried their best to shake off the “classic rock” tag at Red Rocks on Sunday. Photos by Mark T. Osler.

There’s something about seeing a couple classic rock mainstays in an evening at Red Rocks. After all, you’re literally watching a sliver of rock history play out in front of you, along with a few thousand other people, in the best outdoor amphitheater on Earth. What more could you ask for? And from the looks on their faces, most of the audience on Sunday night agreed.

I jumped at a chance to take in Boston and Styx at Red Rocks for a few reasons — mostly to add some historical perspective to the list of bands I’ve seen over the years, and bands I grew up listening to as a child of the ’70s, and to bring my younger son Sandisz (he’s 10) to see some of that history in action (this would be the second time in a few years that Sandisz will have seen Styx).

On those terms, both bands delivered an adequate performance — and were even pretty exciting at times. Each set was performed impeccably and showed the evidence of either act’s years of touring, recording, touring, and recording, and the last 10 years of (mostly) just the touring. Just about everything is rote at this point, which is not to say the bands didn’t deliver what everyone paid for. Nostalgia is what it is.

Of the two, Styx seems to be the band with an ax to grind about being on classic rock radio’s heavy rotation — selling T-shirts with a bold “Classic Rock MY ASS” printed across the back, over a listing of highlights form the more than 1,100 shows they’ve played over the last ten years. This is the shirt my son picked (Styx is one of his fave classic rock bands), though I told him I doubted he’d be able to wear that one to school … yet.

Trying to prove that they’re anything but classics, Styx took the stage pretty much right on time at 7:30 p.m. and offered up a well-practiced arena set, filled with a fairly complete selection of all the hits Styx fans want to hear. The audience screamed approval at Tommy Shaw’s high energy antics. Running manically across the stage through the whole set, he still cuts an early thirtysomething figure.

The rest of the band performed well, offering hits like “Come Sail Away,” “Lady,” “Fooling Yourself,” “Babe” and “Renegade,” among others. The band played to near-album perfection, in performances studded with signature lengthy guitar and keyboard solos. As usual in Styx productions, Dennis DeYoung’s Lawrence Gowan’s keyboard antics were a highlight, with DeYoung Gowan spinning the entire keyboard platform around on its custom merry-go-round, and dancing around and on and off the platform as it spun, all the while keeping up with the music.

After intermission, Boston hit the stage just as the sun was pulling its last rays over the horizon, starting off with Tom Scholz’s famous instrumental rendition of “The Star Spangled Banner.” From there they played through the list of their biggest hits: “Amanda” (a special tour-only rendition, according to Scholz), “Don’t Look Back,” “Peace of Mind,” “More Than a Feeling,” “Foreplay/Longtime” and a special version of “To Be A Man,” dedicated to former lead singer of nearly 30 years, Brad Delp.

Scholz, backed by longtime band members Gary Pihl (guitar), Kimberley Dahme (bass), and Jeff Neale (drums), and newcomers Michael Sweet (formerly recently of Christian metal band Stryper) and Tommy DeCarlo — who has his own Warholian 15 minutes going on — played technically masterful renditions of each of the hits, full of the requisite guitar, drum, and keyboard/organ solos, all examples of Scholz’s genius at work. All in all, Boston’s set could not have exemplified a more proficient and complete band. They played nearly every song the audience expected to hear, and played them well.

Speaking of Tommy DeCarlo, this Denver audience got its first glimpse of DeCarlo, the Charlotte, N.C. Home Depot Credit Manager that replaced the late Brad Delp in the slot of lead vocals for Boston, in a kind of 21st-century, MySpace Cinderella Story (see also Journey).

For those of you who don’t know, Boston’s former lead vocalist Brad Delp was found dead in his New England home in 2007 — an apparent suicide — just before Boston was to go on tour. DeCarlo wrote a song honoring the late singer, and his daughter taught him how to build a MySpace site to get it on the web. They uploaded the song, along with some karaoke versions of other Boston songs, which led to another Boston fan sending Tommy an old email address for someone still in the Boston organization. This eventually led to Tom Scholz asking Tommy to fill in for Brad at a fund raiser on Massachusetts.

Ultimately, DeCarlo was asked to sing with the band on their 2008 tour, making DeCarlo a winner of a sort of “American Idol” journey — and avoiding Randy, Simon and Paula all the way. Tommy wasn’t too shabby on Sunday, either, splitting vocal duties with singer/guitarist Michael Sweet and bassist Kimberley Dahme. Sound engineering at Red Rocks, however, did seem to be having trouble keeping the vocal mix consistent, and both Tommy and Michael Sweet faded in and out occasionally, leaving gaps in some songs.

So, after it was all over, the show (and the night) was overall satisfying, and I know from the look on most of the faces of the crowd (made up of much broader age range than I would have frankly thought), that the bands were accepted well.

When I asked Sandisz to boil down what he thought of the show into one word, he paused for a second, then said “Great!” As I started writing, he came up to me and said: “Dad, I have a more descriptive word: OK?” “Sure,” I said, and he left me with “Waffles!”

Not too sure what that meant, but it sounds more punk to me every time I think of it…

Billy Thieme is a Denver-based writer and Reverb contributor.

Mark T. Osler is a Pulitzer Prize-winning photographer and Reverb contributor.

MORE PHOTOS:

Categories: REVERB
  • Edyth

    Research, research, research. Wasn’t that phrase drill into your head in journalism classes. With a quick check at Styxworld.com you woould have known that Dennis DeYoung hasn’t been with the band since 1999. The vocalist/keyboard player since that time is Lawrance Gowan.

  • styxfan

    Hey Billy -

    Just an FYI, Dennis DeYoung is no longer with STYX — that was Lawrence Gowan.

    Styx Fan

  • Bill

    Nice job – Dennis DeYouns hasn’t been in Styx for many years now – that’s Lawrence Gowan.

  • terry

    wow, i’m not sure what show you were watching, but it’s not the one at red rocks on 7/13. styx was (were?) great. but boston was not. it was not sound problems that caused the problems. decarlo (apparently) had a cold and only sang about 1 and 1/2 songs. the rest of the vocals for the remainder of the night were carried by the band but they weren’t very good filling in for a lead vocalist.
    didn’t you notice the crowd bailing out before the concert was over? didn’t you notice they didn’t even do an encore? i think the band was so disappointed and embarrassed by their performance they couldn’t wait to get out of there.

  • Anonymous

    Yeah I don’t know what concert this “reviewer” went to… I agree that Styx was awesome, however they did not play “Lady” or “Babe” and as stated by other commenters, Dennis DeYoung has not been with the band for nearly a decade.

    But… Boston was a great disappointment. Home Depot man Tommy DeCarlo apparently had a cold and so for every song but the first couple he jumped around pointing at the crowd, banging a tambourine and went to the microphone to sing but it seriously sounded like his microphone was turned off. This went on for 2 songs as everyone around us was looking at each other because there were NO LEAD VOCALS coming through. Then Tom Scholz told the crowd that Tommy had a cold and was having trouble with the singing and “we might miss a few lines here and there”. Well, the last 45 minutes to hour of the show basically sounded like the greatest Karaoke mix of Boston songs you’d ever heard- awesome instrumentals, no lead vocals… I had to resort to closing my eyes and singing the songs in my head so I wasn’t so disappointed with my >$80 purchase for row 12 seats. Boston appeared to have one purpose to their set- get to the end of it so they can get off stage, heck the house lights were on before the bandmembers were even off and that was after the main set- no encore.

    I don’t know what you do when the lead singer can’t sing… but you have to do something more than give an ampitheater full of people who paid very decent money a karaoke mix…

    Kellan
    kellan55@hotmail.com

  • StryperKen

    Michael Sweet is still with Stryper, he is NOT the Former lead singer of Stryper. In fact, Stryper recorded Peace of Mind by Boston and Tom Scholz of Boston joined them on the song. It is out as a single right now and is charting on Itunes. The reason that Tommy’s voice cut out is because he had a cold. He lost his voice and was unable to continue singing at the right level for the rest of the night. Tom Scholz made that clear during the show.

  • Dennis DeYoung

    DeYoung hasn’t been in the band since 1999, dude!!!!!

    DO SOME RESEARCH!!!!

  • Matt C

    The post actually let’s this guy write reviews? What a mess! How in the world could he miss basic band details, set lists, and the fact that Boston had no lead vocals for 80% of the show? And this is supposed to be a paper of record? I’ll do the job for free, and I’ll make sure the information is correct at no additional charge!

  • James JY Young

    This is JY. We booted DDY out of the band in 1999, but we don’t advertise it because it is in our best interests if people believe he is still in the band and pay money to come see our shows.

    Even still, I’m not sure what concert you went to…we don’t play cringe-inducing songs like Babe or Lady any more, and never will.

  • Phyllis

    Styx has not done “Babe” in 9 years. And that is how long DDY has NOT been with the band. did you even go to the concert?

  • Hobbs

    Who follows Stryper? Good god.

  • http://www.getrealdenver.com/ John Wenzel

    Reverb writers are typically not Denver Post employees (unless identified as such) but rather freelancers. That’s not to say we don’t have the same standards for accuracy for both, because we do, but just a clarification.

  • krisha

    I’d like to hear DeCarlo sing without a cold, since it seemed like he was a karaoke singer, at best – in his demeanor and overall vocal ability. Has anyone heardthi guy sing??? I was really expecting Boston to replace their lead vocalist like Journey did; but, was very disappointed with what I heard (albeit cold plagued or not)

  • KBA

    Billy: Nice article and review – one correction; Dennis DeYoung is no longer in STYX, hasn’t been for years. You were watching the superb Lawrence Gowan who has been on keyboard/vocals since around 2001. An accomplished singer/songwriter/musician in his own right, Gowan hails from Canada and was recruited into the band by JY following DeYoung’s departure earlier this century. And, having seen Styx on many occasions in the past several years, I agree wholeheartedly with your son; Styx are indeed “Waffle” – and then some…

  • Lawrence Gowan

    I get no respect!

  • Haywood

    I will agree with a couple people here. First, Lady and Babe were not on the set list and yes, DDY is long gone. Styx actually looked and sounded like a band but Boston was horrible. I don’t for a second believe that DeCarlo had a “cold”,and if you go online you will see this is a recurring issue.

    I am a huge Boston fan and almost left early myself but stuck it out and Foreplay/Longtime was a nice finish with Michael Sweet handling the vocals. But as another perosn pointed out, they couldn’t get off the stage fast enough and no encore. They knew they were terrible, no reason to make the audience endure more toruture. Now if Tom Scholtz would only give me my money back.

    BTW, the writer of this article should be ashamed. If you thought that was a good show, I have some ocean front property for sale.

  • Paul BS

    I was very pleased with Styx, but then again I have seen them once a year for the past 8 years. I had seen Boston twice in the past, once at Red Rocks, and in a word they ‘sucked’. Never been so disapointed in my life with a live show. I left after 5 songs, had to stop the bleeding from my ears, and I am one who bought the re-mastered cd’s released a couple years ago.

  • Chris

    I can’t agree more with most of the comments posted about Boston … except for the writer who was paid to provide this review. Was he at the same show that I was?!?!? This show was absolutely the biggest waste of money!!! If your lead singer has a cold, then reschedule your show so that your fans get what they have paid for!!! Don’t waste our money (and time) with filler instrumentals and no lead vocals!!! A BIG disappointment!!!!

  • Donstr

    Billy, Styx was great, Boston was not. You must’ve left early during the Boston performance as many of the crowd did.

  • BigB

    I thought this reviewed rocked!! Who cares who played the “keyboreds”! Guitars are the real power in rock! Also, I wouldn’t be bragging if a dude from Styper was in my band!

  • pete

    Styx was incridble, what a tight band that totally rocked!! Boston on the other hand was less than impressive – i was one of the thousands that cut out early, something i rarely do. I guess they needed a guy from Lowes to back up the guy from Home Depot!!

  • MontanaJim

    I flew from Montana to see this concert. While Red Rocks as a concert venue is fantastic, the management of it is one of the poorest I have ever seen. From my experience, there is little communication between management and any of the vendors or their own employees. I sent an e mail to Ron Garrison, Guest Services Manager at Red Rocks about the problems we encountered. I received a sanitized version of “we did what we could, not much else we can do” reply. Red Rocks could be so much more if it was properly operated. The “Gorge” in Seattle puts Red Rocks to shame. (And I’m not even from Seattle).

    As for Boston, that is the worst performance by a major band that I have ever seen. Boston has always been one of my favorite bands and I was very disappointed by the meltdown that happened that night. Styx totally rocked the place and set Boston up for a complete rock show. Instead, we have a singer who can’t hit the high ranges that Brad Delp could, so he is helped by the female backup singer. It worked extremely well on “Don’t Look Back”, the best song they did that night. Then the total collapse on “More Than a Feeling”. Then they decided it was best to put on a bar band jam. While many people left, the rest sat on their hands. Another concert first, people sitting down (most of the crowd) halfway through a big concert. They finally got a fair number of people up for “Long Time”, but way too late. Another first for me….the headliner band that didn’t play an encore and nobody that wanted one. What a waste of money.

  • A Roadie

    I sincerely hope everyone who reads down this far understands that DDY, JY , and Lawrence Gowan would never actually write the responses above, or for that matter than any major artist would ever comment electronically on any review, regardless of content. It is perplexing that people would post in the name of these (or any) artists, but it reinforces the adage that one should not believe everything one sees in print.

  • Biily Bogowen

    I can hear Ole Tommy Scholz screaming at his cover band in the dressing room from here!

  • len moses

    well i am a big boston fan and i believe that if tommy doesn’t work out, then tom can have michael sweet and bring back fran cosmo!!!!!! there will never be another brad delp but fran can sure hit those high notes. thing is, something caught tom sholtz attention when he first heard tommy decarlo, so he had a bad night, we all have those every now and then.

  • CRA

    Well, it was not a fluke at Red Rocks. I saw the show last night in St. Louis. My only regret is not reading the comments above prior to buying the tickets. Boston was a joke!! The lead singer was a statue standing center stage. Sorry, every once in awhile he would wave his hands. You could barely hear him at all, which was fine. I made it through 6 songs and had to leave.

    Styx was great. They are absolutely worth seeing. Just wait for them to tour with a band other than Boston.

  • Afton Lees

    I have seen Boston and Styx several times this tour. Tommy DeCarlo is doing an excellent job and the reviews have been outstanding. Red Rocks, though, was not a good one as he could hardly even talk prior to showtime (they said this on the radio).

    I will say, though, the reviews on both the Styx and Boston boards have been kick ass. I got to see them 4 times this summer and Tommy has been wowing crowds everywhere. But, I will agree, Red Rocks was the worst one that I saw. The fans on both fan boards have said the same thing.

    These things happen, man, it sucks, but the rest of the tour, Boston has rawked the house!!

  • A.Kobinaugh

    I saw that concert too and admittedly Styx was the best of the two bands overall. I also saw Boston in KC thinking that the Denver show must have just been a fluke and Tommy Decarlo was no better there as he barely sang on most of the songs and when he did there was not even an attempt to hit any high notes! Its a shame that auditions weren’t held for the lead singer poisition of Boston because I absolutely know who should have gotten the job his name is bill bishop and he is the singer for a Boston tribute band in KC called 4th stage and their vidoes are all over you-tube. I will be amazed of Scholz doesen’t fire decarlo before the end of the tour. Go back to Home depo Tommy decarlo and give Tom Scholz a chance to salvage his band!

  • Kelly

    Wow. I can’t believe what happened at the Denver show. Sorry to hear it. Just wanted to say that I was at the Jones Beach (NY) show last night and Boston was unbelievable. DeCarlo and Sweet both did vocals and they were amazing. I want you guys to see the show from last night because it was a high-energy, highly entertaining show. They played for an hour and a half with a two song encore – Smokin’ & Party. They were really excellent. REO Speedwagon was pretty good, too.